Entry #2

Be constructive!

2015-06-14 10:36:07 by EnviousBass

Don’t you just hate it when people can rate something without giving an explanation why they rated it that specific way? I don’t have a problem when people like something and they give a good rating, because good rating automatically come with the “yeah I like that” feel to them. Comments and actual critique would be nice too but are not really required there. 

But what’s really annoying are bad ratings without comments, critique or the like. With a bad rating people say “meh, don’t like that”. The artist would like to know WHY that is though, so they can improve their work. Otherwise this can be a hell of a lot discouraging. Believe me, I know what I’m talking about.

If you rate something, always, always, always leave a comment with your thoughts on the work. Be constructive! Help other people, artists in particular (and that includes writing, drawing, music, any kind of creative content), to improve their work. Artists come to platforms like Newgrounds, tumblr, etc. because they want people to participate in what they create and they pour their souls into their creations. The least you can do is honor that by leaving a piece of constructive criticism. It’s not that hard, just write them your thoughts, how you felt when you saw/read/heard it etc. It helps tremendously!

Oh and by the way… if you don’t like something because you don’t like stuff like that in general (e.g. you’re not a fan of techno but want to rate a techno song) don’t do it. Biased ratings are the worst. Stay objective! :)


You must be logged in to comment on this post.


2015-06-14 10:44:02

yeah ok i'll keep that in mind


2015-07-08 04:52:42

Well said!


2015-07-30 02:54:49

Objective ratings are impossible, in my oppinion. Even if you like the genre, ypu might dislike certain decisions the artist has made. This applies to both creative and technical decisions. Even when it comes to the mixdown, the final mix is ultimately a sum of decisions the producer has made and that you might or might not agree with. "Getting better" is highly subjective. In my opinion, it doesnt matter if you "get better" or not. What matters that at the end of the day, you have finished a song you're happy with and were able to make your idea of how it is supposed to sound come true. Whether other people agree with idea or not is out of your control.
However, I do see that, when you're starting off, you might need some feedback from people with trained ears and some routine as it can make your life easier trying to achieve your own sound.
But judging by your tracks, you're not just starting off and have a good deal of expertise and routine in producing.
Dont give a shit about feedback. Do what you want.


2016-01-21 13:56:53

Yeah, I always try to encourage people to be more constructive. But honestly, they don't WANT to be. Those that can't do, review. It's almost like a weird kind of self-entitled jealousy.